A long time ago, in a country far, far away, my mother took me to
see a Spanish-dubbed version of Star Wars (A New Hope) when I was four
years old. I didn't understand all of it back then but it sure did capture
my attention and my imagination. Three years later my father (rest in
peace) took me to see The Empire Strikes Back, this time it was with Spanish
subtitles. I was seven so I had some trouble keeping up with the subtitles
but understood what was going on. Many years later Revenge of the Sith
comes along to bring closure to the saga of this futuristic fairytale
for the modern day children of today (and yesterday like myself.) Despite
any of the bad things about these movies I consider it a very special
time when one is premiering at the theaters. There are so many emotional
ties with Star Wars for me to do a straight review of the film. Still,
I feel that I may be able to do so.
Episode III-Revenge
of the Sith is the final chapter in the coming of age story of Anakin
Skywalker as he becomes Darth Vader Lord of the Sith. Darth Vader is a
tragic figure, a man who had many things going for him yet had so much
go wrong in his life from the start. Hayden Christensen is Anakin, who
delivers a better performance than in Attack of the Clones yet still does
not pack enough punch for his role. Anakin is a man haunted by nightmares
of his fears and remorse from being unable to save his mother from death.
As a Jedi he has the occasional visions into the future which only add
to his fears and ultimately lead him into the Dark Side. Most people already
know how this story is supposed to end and what makes the movie interesting
is in providing the details and answering a few questions along the way.
Ewan McGregor (Obi-Wan
Kenoby,) Natalie Portman (Padme Skywalker,) and Samuel L. Jackson (Mace
Windu) do offer decent supporting roles in a movie where the acting and
dialog are far from the main focus. Not much is seen from Mace Windu,
and Padme seems to be stuck in room for most of the film. I think there
were too many issues the film needed to present that it did not allow
it to do much with so many characters. Like the previous two films, the
acting is a bit sterile and the dialog is weak. The tender moments between
Anakin and Padme don't really work and many of the lines make you cringe.
The screen play is better in this film that the previous two as George
Lucas consulted with a professional screen writer for the first time since
Return of the Jedi. It is better, but it is not necessary good. I really
don't know why Lucas did not hire a screen writer for these films as they
would have greatly improved the finished product.
Ian McDiarmid (Emperor
Palpatine) offers the best display of acting in this film. I don't feel
the other cast members failed though, but they were limited by their lines
and Lucas' work as director. Palpatine corrupts and deceives Anakin by
playing on the young man's emotion. Anakin loves Padme very deeply and
his fear of losing her is his greatest weakness. George Lucas does succeed
in developing this premise and presents a story that flows very well.
From beginning to end the viewer is allowed to be completely involved
in the storyline and there are no lags or questionable editing. The film
has great action and special effects and they are tied together with the
flow of the plot in excellent fashion. This is the strength of this film,
and displays Lucas' talent as a story teller. If only he had allowed others
to help him with the other aspects of film making that are not his strong
points.
The ending in this film does a good job in tying it together with the
film that follows it. Cameos by Grand Moff Tarkin and Captain Antilles
help bring it full circle. The character of Darth Vader is fully understood
at the end which was the goal here. Of the current installments in this
series this film is clearly the best and does deliver what it promises.
I feel the arrangement of the storyline for the prequels could have been
shaped better but Revenge of the Sith was their salvation. I really did
enjoy this movie a great deal and most of it was done very well even though
I focused a bit on some of its shortcomings. The best approach to this
film is to evaluate it as a whole, and look at the big picture. Sure it
has its shortcomings but anyone who enjoys fantasy, or had any connection
with Star Wars growing up will not be disappointed by this movie.
|